I don’t think they reached the top, because they don’t have enough knowledge and modern equipment. And the difficult path, I don’t think they can climb the mountain by their poor equipment.
Yes,I think they reached the top, even with poor equipment. It's difficult but they do. They reached the top by their persistent heart. And I like the happy ending.
I don't think they reached to the top, the reason is their equipments and tools, even nowadays climbing equipments can't reached to the top 100% safely, not to mention the date they climbed, if they reached it, it must be a miracle.
Summary: The summit of mountain Everest the tallest piece of land on earth, in the past century, many climbers who dared to challenge this beast of a mountain died on their way to the top, in which the mystery of 2 early climber named Mallory and Irvine is yet to be solved, till this day, nobody knows whether they've reached the summit, and Mallory's body was discovered on the way to the top but Irvine was never discovered.
I'd like to think they reached the top since its more romantic that way. But i think its unlikely that they did since the extreme conditions and the leack of equipments they have to deal with was unimaginably hard, even to this day climbing mount Everest is still considered an extreme sport and to conquer mountain Everest would be considered an significant achievement for anyone.
H106A151 秦藝庭 According to this article, I don't think they reached the top. With the equipment of that era, I don't think they can overcome the severe climate to reach the top of the Everest. Although no picture of his wife was found on him, it may have been accidentally lost. Besides, the body of Irvine has not been found.
U105A121 1. This is the story of two people climbing. Some people believe that they really reached the top of the mountain but some people don't think so. Later, when a team wanted to go up the mountain to try it, they found some traces, and also found the body of one of them. They think the reason they didn't reach the top of the mountain was because the equipment at the time was not enough to get them to the top of the mountain, which was too dangerous. 2.I think they didn’t reach the top Everest because the article say that their equipment is to poor and the way to the summit is to dangerous.
I don't think so. It was not easy to be limited by equipment, talents and technology in that era. I tried to reach the summit three times. The two did not go down alive at the end. Did Mallory and Irving reach the summit? It is a difficult mystery. - H106A136
H106A140 柯瓊惠 No, they don’t reached the top of Everest. In the end the expedition found Mallory’s body and then able to piece together exactly what had happened to him in his last hours on Everest. Mallory had died before he reached the top.
Although the article said, their body had no sign of frostbite, I think maybe their body are not too sensitive about the weather, and nobody knew whether they exactly reached the top of Everest or not. But if they could be said that they were the first people to reach the top of Mount Everest, I think it’s literally a reliable mystery, nobody will say that they had reach the top of the mountain without any evidence. So I think they had reached the top.
H106A129謝羽雯 I don’t think they reachthe top, because it ’s a difficult thing, how many people are killed there, and it takes a lot of preparation to reach the top of Mount Everest.
Maybe were the first men to reach the summit of Mount Everest. But new research suggests the pair could never have conquered the world's highest mountain but were instead killed by a “perfect storm”.
1.Some people think that Mallory and Irvine were the first person to reach the top of Mount Everest. So the team was sent to investigate. However, only Mallory's body was found. There were many doubts prove that they could not reach the top. So far this cannot be sure. 2. I think they didn’t reach the top of Everest because the article says that they didn’t have enough equipments and no frostbites on the body. It is strange.
I don't think so. Because I think the state of technology has not reached.It ’s dangerous for people to try challenges.So the danger of climbing to the peak is very high.
I don’t think they reached the top,because they don’t have enough equipment and it was difficult to reach the the top with current technology. Not to mention that era
OC108046 許湘伶 I don't think they reached the top, because they don't have climbing modern equipment. Moreover, no sign of frosbite was found on Mallory’s body. I think it's unreasonable to have no frostbite in such cold weather, so I guess they didn't reach the top of Everest.
The climbing team found Mallory's body on the north slope of the Everest at about 8190 meters above sea level, but the climbing team did not find the Kodak camera they carried, so it is still impossible to confirm whether the two have reached the summit.
I think they are not reach the summit because equipment is not good enough to climb. Article also provides some information, they did not reach top of Everest but were close to the top.
No, I think they didn’t. First, we didn’t find the photo of Mallory’s wife. Second, it's hard to climb Everest's Second Step without the right tools. Third, Mallory’s body had no sign of frostbite. Base on these reasons, I don’t think they reach the top of Everest.
No,because the climate at high altitudes is changing rapidly, not only can mountain training be successful over the years. Climate is often the main key. A snowstorm may also bring a fatal crisis. Moreover, the physical strength required for climbing is very large, at least more than ten hours, and the oxygen consumption is high, so I don't think they can reach the top of Everest.
In my opinion, Irvine reached the top of Everest. Mallory didn’t reach the summit. Irvine may died on the summit so climbers didn’t find Irvine’s body. Climbers couldn’t find Mallory’s photo because Irvine maybe took it and put it on the summit.
I don’t think they reached the top, because they don’t have enough knowledge and modern equipment. And the difficult path, I don’t think they can climb the mountain by their poor equipment.
回覆刪除I don't think so. No any evidence to support they reach the top. Look at their equipment, obviously.
回覆刪除Yes,I think they reached the top, even with poor equipment.
回覆刪除It's difficult but they do. They reached the top by their persistent heart.
And I like the happy ending.
I don't think they reached to the top, the reason is their equipments and tools, even nowadays climbing equipments can't reached to the top 100% safely, not to mention the date they climbed, if they reached it, it must be a miracle.
回覆刪除Summary: The summit of mountain Everest the tallest piece of land on earth, in the past century, many climbers who dared to challenge this beast of a mountain died on their way to the top, in which the mystery of 2 early climber named Mallory and Irvine is yet to be solved, till this day, nobody knows whether they've reached the summit, and Mallory's body was discovered on the way to the top but Irvine was never discovered.
回覆刪除I'd like to think they reached the top since its more romantic that way. But i think its unlikely that they did since the extreme conditions and the leack of equipments they have to deal with was unimaginably hard, even to this day climbing mount Everest is still considered an extreme sport and to conquer mountain Everest would be considered an significant achievement for anyone.
H106A151 秦藝庭
回覆刪除According to this article, I don't think they reached the top. With the equipment of that era, I don't think they can overcome the severe climate to reach the top of the Everest. Although no picture of his wife was found on him, it may have been accidentally lost. Besides, the body of Irvine has not been found.
U105A121
回覆刪除1. This is the story of two people climbing. Some people believe that they really reached the top of the mountain but some people don't think so. Later, when a team wanted to go up the mountain to try it, they found some traces, and also found the body of one of them. They think the reason they didn't reach the top of the mountain was because the equipment at the time was not enough to get them to the top of the mountain, which was too dangerous.
2.I think they didn’t reach the top Everest because the article say that their equipment is to poor and the way to the summit is to dangerous.
OC108076王惠昭
回覆刪除OC108077徐瑋釩
We think they died halfway before reaching the top.or they gave up before they reached the top.
I don't think so. It was not easy to be limited by equipment, talents and technology in that era. I tried to reach the summit three times. The two did not go down alive at the end. Did Mallory and Irving reach the summit? It is a difficult mystery.
回覆刪除-
H106A136
H106A117顏偌愉
回覆刪除No, I don’t think they reach the top.Because there is no evidence to prove their succeed .
I think it is still a miracle.
No,they doesn't reached the top of Everst.They vanish on second step.But they camp on mountain at night.So they dead on the Everst mountain.
回覆刪除H106A140 柯瓊惠
回覆刪除No, they don’t reached the top of Everest. In the end the expedition found Mallory’s body and then able to piece together exactly what had happened to him in his last hours on Everest. Mallory had died before he reached the top.
H106A128 張淑惠
回覆刪除I don't think they peaked because they didn't have enough knowledge. , I don't think they can climb this mountain with bad equipment.
Although the article said, their body had no sign of frostbite, I think maybe their body are not too sensitive about the weather, and nobody knew whether they exactly reached the top of Everest or not. But if they could be said that they were the first people to reach the top of Mount Everest, I think it’s literally a reliable mystery, nobody will say that they had reach the top of the mountain without any evidence. So I think they had reached the top.
回覆刪除No, they did not climb the Everest, because if they climbed to the Everest, it would be recorded in history.
回覆刪除H106A132鄭侑昇
H106A129謝羽雯
回覆刪除I don’t think they reachthe top, because it ’s a difficult thing, how many people are killed there, and it takes a lot of preparation to reach the top of Mount Everest.
H106A113 章詩曼
回覆刪除No, Mallory had died before he reached the top.
Maybe were the first men to reach the summit of Mount Everest. But new research suggests the pair could never have conquered the world's highest mountain but were instead killed by a “perfect storm”.
回覆刪除1.Some people think that Mallory and Irvine were the first person to reach the top of Mount Everest. So the team was sent to investigate. However, only Mallory's body was found. There were many doubts prove that they could not reach the top. So far this cannot be sure.
回覆刪除2. I think they didn’t reach the top of Everest because the article says that they didn’t have enough equipments and no frostbites on the body. It is strange.
I don't think so. Because I think the state of technology has not reached.It ’s dangerous for people to try challenges.So the danger of climbing to the peak is very high.
刪除I don’t think they reached the top,because they don’t have enough equipment and it was difficult to reach the the top with current technology. Not to mention that era
回覆刪除I don't think so, because they don't have a perfect equipment and the chances of survival are low in the absence of knowledge.
回覆刪除OC108046 許湘伶
回覆刪除I don't think they reached the top, because they don't have climbing modern equipment.
Moreover, no sign of frosbite was found on Mallory’s body.
I think it's unreasonable to have no frostbite in such cold weather, so I guess they didn't reach the top of Everest.
賴怡如 has sent you a link to a blog:
回覆刪除The climbing team found Mallory's body on the north slope of the Everest at about 8190 meters above sea level, but the climbing team did not find the Kodak camera they carried, so it is still impossible to confirm whether the two have reached the summit.
黃威皓
回覆刪除下午7:43 (3 小時前)
寄給 我
I think they are not reach the summit because equipment is not good enough to climb. Article also provides some information, they did not reach top of Everest but were close to the top.
No, I think they didn’t. First, we didn’t find the photo of Mallory’s wife. Second, it's hard to climb Everest's Second Step without the right tools. Third, Mallory’s body had no sign of frostbite. Base on these reasons, I don’t think they reach the top of Everest.
回覆刪除陳采青 H106A150
回覆刪除李 琬真
下午7:55 (3 小時前)
寄給 我
No,because the climate at high altitudes is changing rapidly, not only can mountain training be successful over the years. Climate is often the main key. A snowstorm may also bring a fatal crisis. Moreover, the physical strength required for climbing is very large, at least more than ten hours, and the oxygen consumption is high, so I don't think they can reach the top of Everest.
H106A131 王銘笙
回覆刪除Whether you reach the top
But I think the process of climbing
I have achieved a lot in my heart
I have reached the top of the mountain
In my opinion, Irvine reached the top of Everest. Mallory didn’t reach the summit.
回覆刪除Irvine may died on the summit so climbers didn’t find Irvine’s body.
Climbers couldn’t find Mallory’s photo because Irvine maybe took it and put it on the summit.
H106A147
梓維李
回覆刪除下午7:58 (3 小時前)
寄給 我
Whether they climb to the top,
a link to their mentality,strong mentality, firm eyes
It's more than the height of the mountain.
I don't think they reached the top, Because there is no evidence that they climbed to the top,Equipment is not enough，So I don't think they succeed
回覆刪除NO.Because of the poor equipment and no evidence to prove that they have reached the top of Everest.
回覆刪除H106A118